5 Consumer Tax Return Strategies (and their Underlying Mentality)

April 18th is Tax Day, and with taxes being top-of-mind for every American, we asked more than 750 consumers from across the country about their tax strategy and behavior. By listening to how consumers approach their tax preparations, filing strategies, and point of views on refunds, we gleaned a handful of insights that go beyond simply when and how they file.

Andrew Johnston

Consultant at C Space

Rachel Smooke

Senior Consultant at C Space

In 1789, Benjamin Franklin penned a letter to a French scientist named Jean-Baptiste Leroy. “In this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes,” Franklin wrote.

Centuries later, this idiom remains true. While we all acknowledge the certainty of taxes, there’s value – and we think Ben would agree – in understanding the human aspect behind them, to focus on the whys behind people’s tax-time behaviors. For instance: do people employ a specific, even ritualistic, yearly tax strategy? And if so, what is the philosophy or mentality underpinning that strategy? What will they choose to do if they receive a refund or have to pay, and why?

With April 18th, Tax Day, days away, and taxes being top-of-mind for every American, we asked more than 750 consumers from across the country about their tax strategy and behavior. By listening to how consumers approach their tax preparations, filing strategies, and point of views on refunds, we gleaned a handful of insights that go beyond simply when and how they file.

Regardless of how consumers file their taxes (e.g., on paper, tax software, a tax accountant), we discovered five strategies and underlying mentalities driving their choices and behaviors.

1. Hoping it’s BIG

Individuals employing this “strategy” (if you want to call it one) typically don’t pay much attention to their taxes other than at the filing stage. Their tax-time mentality is simple: the bigger the refund the better. Rather than take an active, strategic approach to filing their taxes, many will use self-service providers, like TurboTax, to guide them through the filing process and help them maximize their refund. It’s their yearly tax “routine,” and if they receive a larger return than in previous years, they are thrilled.

To these consumers, tax refund equals free money. It’s an annual bonus they depend on, and they spend it as such. Vacations, home improvements, major life events (such as weddings), or other big ticket items are common refund splurges. Often, these spend areas are earmarked in their yearly budgets well before the refund hits their bank accounts.

2. Making it BIG

There’s another group of individuals who want to achieve the same outcome (get as big of a return as possible), but for an entirely different reason. Rather than passively file their taxes, they take a proactive and strategic approach, doing all they can, all year long, to lower their taxable income and ensure they get the largest refund possible. This approach takes many forms. For example, these individuals will adjust exemption claims (e.g., reducing 1 to 0), max out IRAs, contribute to pre-tax health savings accounts, or employ tax write-off strategies such as charitable donations.

Instead of spending their tax return windfall immediately on a new flat-screen TV or dishwasher, these strategic and calculated individuals seek investing and savings products that will grow their return for long-term benefit.

The remaining three strategies each have the same goal: to neither receive a refund nor owe any money. As a result, behaviors in regards to refunds (if any) are similar. The nuanced difference between the groups is in the underlying mentality for breaking even.

3. Playing it safe

These financially savvy consumers don’t want to be in a position where they owe the government any money. They acknowledge that ideally they’d like to come out net-zero, but they would also opt to receive a refund on the smaller side at the expense of breaking even.

As a result, many of these consumers will slightly overpay on their taxes. Maintaining a consistent income throughout the year – versus earning a few extra dollars per month in bank account interest – combined with the knowledge that they won’t owe any money come April gives them peace of financial mind.

4. Putting my money to work

Fiscally shrewd, these consumers also want to neither receive nor owe any money after filing their taxes. They prefer to receive their money as they earn it (vs. the government holding it until they issue a tax return), and they manage that money wisely.

Their strategy is about the long game. It’s about investing one’s own funds in real-time in order to earn interest and grow over the long-term. One consumer explained this mindset: “Our investment accounts grew at about 15% last year, so I’d rather have my money there than with the government…especially 20 years from now when it’s made a huge difference with compounding interest!”

5. Sticking it to Uncle Sam

These consumers also want to break even come tax time, and they acknowledge the loss of potential interest earned throughout the year, but for another reason entirely. They don’t want to give the government a “free loan.” They are more concerned with who their money is being used by rather than what they are missing out on by not having access to it throughout the year.

Money is an intensely personal and emotional thing. And, every April, Tax Day brings that truth to light. Inside that truth is nuance. That’s why understanding consumers’ tax strategies and their underlying mentalities is so important. It gives insight into why people behave how they do when it comes to saving, spending, and planning. And it gives us a better sense of both their decision making processes and the pain points they experience – not just come tax time, but all the time.

You may be interested in:

Kate Tellers, The Moth: Principles of Great Storytelling

Kate Tellers, The Moth: Principles of Great Storytelling Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: Stories are the great unifier. When told well, they create a powerful connection to the human experience. No organization knows this better than The Moth. Since...

Peter Fader: Customer Centricity is Not About “The” Customer

Peter Fader: Customer Centricity is Not About “The” Customer Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: Wharton School Professor of Marketing Peter Fader sometimes wishes he never used the words “Customer Centricity” in his first book, Customer Centricity, and...

BAT companies prove the case for customer-centrism

BAT companies prove the case for customer-centrism

by Felix Koch (C Space)
Campaign

Alibaba, Baidu and Tencent have built multi-billion dollar businesses by putting the customer—not the advertiser—at the centre of their thinking, and Western platforms should take note.

Jonah Berger: Social Influence and Word of Mouth

Jonah Berger: Social Influence and Word of Mouth Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: How does anything become popular? And what are the influences that dictate our decisions -- whether we’re conscious of it or not? Wharton School Professor Jonah Berger is...

Gary Pisano: Can Big Companies Really Be Innovative?

Gary Pisano: Can Big Companies Really Be Innovative? Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: Innovation. It’s the most overused buzzword in business. It’s also a catalyst for growth. But is it possible for big companies to be truly innovative? Or are they...

10 Podcasts That Will Change Your Business Life For The Better

10 Podcasts That Will Change Your Business Life For The Better

by Laura Garnett
Inc.

A great way to stay connected to current business trends and news is listening to podcasts. There’s no shortage of channels to tune into, so here is a list of some of the top podcasts – including Outside In with Charles Trevail.

Jeff Blau, CEO, Related: Building a City of the Future

Jeff Blau, CEO, Related: Building a City of the Future Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: Is Hudson Yards the future of urban living? New York City’s newest neighborhood is now home to L’Oréal, SAP, Blackrock, Time Warner, and Coach, just to name a few....

Kate O’Neill: Rise of the Tech Humanist

Kate O'Neill: Rise of the Tech Humanist Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: Understanding what makes humans “human” is an essential question for any company today. Especially the ones embarking on a digital transformation -- or any tech initiative. This...

Francesca Gino: Live (and Work) Like a Rebel

Francesca Gino: Live (and Work) Like a Rebel Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: David Bowie sang about one. Star Wars had an Alliance of them. James Dean portrayed one. Why is it that we admire rebels? Is there value in breaking the rules? Harvard...

Amy Webb: Our Uncertain Future with AI

Amy Webb: Our Uncertain Future with AI Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: How bright or dark will our future be with artificial intelligence? Who will control it? Amy Webb is a quantitative futurist and author of the book, The Big Nine: How the Tech...