A Call to Action: “Humanizing” the Billing & Claims Experience

What patients see as one unified healthcare experience is, in fact, separate and distinct. What is needed is a fundamental rethink and redesign of the billing and claims process. Hospitals can play a key role in enabling this transformation, as can insurers.

Dan Sills

Associate Director at C Space

Dan Sills produces C Space’s customer experience podcast, Outside In, which The Huffington Post called one of “The 7 Best Business Podcasts You Should Be Listening To” and Entrepreneur included in a list of “Best Podcasts for Entrepreneurs.” When he’s not locked in an edit suite, Dan talks at Story Slams and was a 2016 grandSLAM finalist for cult storytelling circle The Moth.

With contributions from Anne Pessala, Amélie Touroyan, and Bethany Klaene.

Put yourself in this situation: It’s the weekend. Your young child is playing in the backyard, climbing an old oak tree, and you hear the crack of breaking branches. You rush your child to the nearest ER, where the intake nurse, doctor, and orthopedist pull out the heroics. They soothe both of you and distract your child from the pain while operating efficiently. It’s as great an experience as a broken bone could be. And it’s over… isn’t it?

Most of the time, the answer to that question is a resounding “no,” and what follows shows there is so much more to the story:

Three months later, you receive a bill in the mail for the treatment: $1460.45. Your stomach sinks as you realize you need to make sacrifices to cover the out-of-pocket costs. The billing codes are inexplicable and you suddenly fear that you are being billed incorrectly. So, you call your hospital, get transferred, and turned away. You call your insurer, and it’s a similar story. Several weeks and many phone calls later, some charges are removed, some remain, and you feel like the stress of repairing a broken arm was less disruptive than the process of paying for it.

The unfortunate truth is that the customer experience (for both patient and caregiver) is actually compartmentalized into a “health” and then a “billing” or “claims” experience. It’s true the professionals demonstrated real care in the exam or hospital room, but the complex billing and claims process that follows can transform this positive experience into a negative, stressful one that customers are often blindsided by and unprepared for.

What patients see as one unified healthcare experience is, in fact, separate and distinct, and organized to optimize “parts” of the process – not the whole. On one side, hospitals handle intake, treatment, discharge, and billing. On the other, insurers manage referrals, co-pays, claims processing, explanation of benefits (EOBs), and provider payment. It’s a complex, fragmented process characterized by handoffs, manual interventions and rules-based decision making. At its best, it is hassle-free for the patient. When there is a problem, it’s confusing, time consuming, and frustrating.

It’s so complex that many third party groups have sprung up, acting as mediators between treatment and payment, smoothing the process over and creating a financially predictable situation for the patient. Remedy helps patients with over-billing; Zest Health helps patients understand and get the most of out of their health benefits; Simplee creates a simple, engaging, beautiful payment experience for the patient. This might work in the short term and provide a much-needed service. However, they are a Band-Aid on a broken system, adding another layer of complexity to equation. If the system worked in a way that kept patients free from the issues that rise between the hospital and insurance company, there wouldn’t be a need for these kinds of concierge services.

What is needed is a fundamental rethink and redesign of the billing/claims process. We need a transformation that aligns more closely with the patients’ view of a unified experience, and is simplified, transparent and trouble-free. Hospitals can play a key role in enabling this transformation, as can insurers.

At minimum, hospitals could inform patients of treatment costs and what is covered/not covered/in network/out of network before services are rendered (or work with insurers to do so). They could make customer service for billing easier for people to access (why is it open only from 8-4 on week days only?) with helpful staff working on a patient’s behalf to solve the problem, not just take the payment.

Insurers also have the opportunity to elevate the customer service and claims function into a strategic asset for customer retention and satisfaction. They could transform call centers by training more staff in customer empathy and giving them access to the records they need in order to be good advisors. Like the hospital billing department, they too could offer to resolve the issue on the patient’s behalf – not force the caller to straddle provider billing groups and the insurer. They could redesign EOB’s to make them clearer, easier to understand, and written in consumer-friendly language. After all, the bottom line for the patient (consumer) is quite simple: is it all taken care of? If not, how much do I have to pay, and why?

The biggest impact for improved customer experience and reduced complexity will only happen through collaboration of hospitals and insurers and others to simplify billing codes, restructure plan and payment levels, reduce handoffs and diminish the potential for human error. A deliberate redesign of the whole experience is necessary – one that creates synergies across the system instead of points of friction, or increased pain. Making progress against this goal is challenging and essential, especially in the current climate of change and uncertainly around future of healthcare. It’s time to upend a system that is ripe and long overdue for disruption, thereby allowing patients to focus on their broken bones, not a broken billing system.

You may be interested in:

Managing Expectations

Managing Expectations

by Katie McQuater, Deputy Editor

Do management consultancies represent a threat, an opportunity, or simply a wake-up call to the market research industry? Katie McQuater takes a look.

What Are the Benefits of Online Communities?

What Are the Benefits of Online Communities?We live in a world where online communities are ubiquitous, with almost every global brand using some form of it to uncover insight that leads to business change. But how exactly do they add value, and what are...

21st Century Market Research

21st Century Market Research Advances in social media, the empowerment of everyday consumers, and the need for more actionable insights fuel a mandate for market research to do more, faster. But the use of social media-driven research also fuels the quality debate...

Healthcare Without Borders

Healthcare Without Borders How Millennials are Reshaping Health and Wellness When it comes to managing their health, Millennials have more access to information, connectivity, and technology than any other generation. Yet, competing financial pressures and government...

Gen Z & the Future of Money

Gen Z & the Future of Money We invited a group of 27 Gen Zers, ages 13 to 20, and six executives from the banking, retail, electronics, and apparel industries, to participate in a full-day interactive session, Gen Z and the Future of Money. The goals for the day were...

Moving at the Speed of Business

Moving at the Speed of Business Or how a little quantification can go a long way The world we live in today comes with an unfamiliar set of demands. Companies, regardless of industry, must be as agile, swift, and decisive as possible. As researchers, we must generate...

Bluemercury’s Barry Beck: Luxe Beauty Meets Anthropology

Bluemercury’s Barry Beck: Luxe Beauty Meets Anthropology Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: It’s been called Macy’s “secret weapon,” its engine for innovation and growth. Since Barry Beck and his wife Marla Beck started Bluemercury in 1999, and sold it...

Nightingale’s Insightful Lessons

Nightingale's Insightful Lessons We all know Florence Nightingale as a British nurse who came to prominence during the Crimean War, and arguably the founder of modern nursing. But she was so much more than that. She was a 19th century insight manager....

Zuora CEO: The Subscription Economy

Zuora CEO: The Subscription Economy Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: Netflix. Spotify. Amazon Prime. These days, we don’t buy, we subscribe. Tien Tzuo, founder and CEO of Zuora, has a name for it: the Subscription Economy. Subscription models open up...

Microsoft Recovers From the Electric Slide

Microsoft Recovers From the Electric Slide In the fashion world, there’s a term that gets used from time to time: effortlessly chic. It’s about looking stylish and on-trend -- seemingly without even trying. In the brand world, I would say there’s a similar...