For Millennials and Their Finances, Today’s Confidence is Tomorrow’s Fear

A recent C Space study of 750 US-based Millennials, predominantly female, points to the issue: a disconnect between Millennial consumers and the financial services industry.

Dan Sills

Associate Director at C Space

Dan Sills produces C Space’s customer experience podcast, Outside In, which The Huffington Post called one of “The 7 Best Business Podcasts You Should Be Listening To” and Entrepreneur included in a list of “Best Podcasts for Entrepreneurs.” When he’s not locked in an edit suite, Dan talks at Story Slams and was a 2016 grandSLAM finalist for cult storytelling circle The Moth.

Forget FOMO. For Millennials’ long-term financial futures, it’s all about FOTU: Fear of the Unknown.

But here’s the rub. When it comes to more short-term financial management – their spending in particular – Millennials feel confident and in control. They excel at responsibilities like living within their means, consolidating and paying off debt, automatically putting a portion of their paycheck into a savings account, and opting for more affordable options when buying big ticket items like cars and homes.

So, why the erosion in financial confidence? A recent C Space study of 750 US-based Millennials, predominantly female, points to the issue: a disconnect between Millennial consumers and the financial services industry. Nearly all Millennials (92 percent) in the study said that being educated on personal finances is important. Further, nearly three-quarters (73 percent) feel confident in their financial decision making ability. But, this confidence does not match with actual financial literacy levels. Despite holding financial education in high regard and having confidence in making financial decisions, only 39 percent said they rely on financial advice from a professional.

Why is that? For this generation, smart spending is the new saving, and short-term relief is the new long-term planning. When they make financial decisions they feel confident about, they feel proud, happy, responsible, safe, accomplished, relaxed, strong, and smart.

But many of these decisions involve interacting with financial institutions on a purely transactional basis – for example, making a credit card payment, a checking account deposit, or transferring money. For the most part, these transactions are devoid of emotion. A lack of emotional connection leads to a lack of trust, and that has ramifications when considering a financial institution for long-term savings and planning.

Adding to this distrust is the feeling that financial institutions don’t really have their back for the long-haul. This results in a further erosion in Millennials’ confidence about their financial futures. With an asset-first industry focus, current outreach and education by financial services companies is primarily dominated by messages of saving and investing. But Millennials have little support from these companies where they feel the least secure: future spending and debt.

Millennials have experienced a shift in values, with a differing view of the world compared to their Boomer parents. Things like job protection and security are no longer a guarantee. They are delaying marriage later than any generation before them. They are delaying buying homes and having children. Why buy a car when you can borrow one with Zipcar or get around with Lyft or Uber?

Simply put, the financial industry is not setting Millennials up for success. As one participant in our study shared, “I haven’t made this decision yet because I am not confident. I would like to refinance my home mortgage but I am unsure where to begin to shop around. I tried to do online research but it just got overwhelming and, to be honest, I simply gave up.”

Financial institutions have a real opportunity here to connect with Millennials on their terms, to speak their language, provide support, build trust, and empower their financial futures.

Firstly, these institutions need to understand that, for Millennials, financial confidence does not mean knowing everything about personal finance. Rather, it’s about knowing what they need to know, when they need to know it. It’s about feeling confident in their ability to make decisions about their personal finances and their futures.

We know that Millennial consumers will talk to professionals who they have a connection to. They are confident about having money in the bank, paying the day-to-day bills, spending smartly and staying out of debt. But it’s the future they are overwhelmed about, and that’s when their confidence dips. Retirement isn’t even on their radar, and funding it isn’t in their realm of understanding.

How can financial services companies convert these customers to varsity-status finance? How can they build long-term relationships for the future? Figure out what’s in it for the customer, and deliver it on their terms?

Gamify the process for instant gratification. Financial providers need to stop talking about things like waived fees, overdraft, and money transfers when most institutions already offer this at no cost. It’s table stakes. Instead, what about providing rewards on “treat yourself” items, like a $3 latte, or a $2 dog treat? Celebrate the little luxuries.

Call it like it is. The financial nomenclature is all wrong. Why not name a product for what Millennials actually use it for? A checking account is a “spending account.” A savings account is used for bucketing money for future purchases like a vacation or new pair of shoes. Why not call it a “rewards account?”

Reposition retirement. Could retirement be positioned as the ultimate cash out reward? Instead of talking about retirement savings, call it “long-term budgeting” to make far-off goals seem more concrete. You saved $500 – congratulations, you don’t have to eat cat food! Or, you set aside $2,000 – you just bought yourself a trip to Peru!

Define the enemy. Banks have never “defined the enemy” for consumers.  For example, for laundry detergent, it’s messy kids. For deodorant, it’s sweat and stink. If banks define the enemy, they could position themselves as a resource for consumers to make smart decisions in a sea of financial traps and temptations.

Some financial companies companies are already taking steps toward a more Millennial-friendly relationship. For example, former Wall Street executive Sallie Krawcheck created Ellevest, a robo-advising platform for women, by women. Ellevest is personalized for each user’s financial situation and customized to meet their specific goals. The platform uses playful, yet respectful, tone and imagery that not only resonates with Millennials, but contributes to increasing their long-term financial confidence.

There’s a real opportunity for financial institutions to innovate. Banks are sitting on a goldmine of customers, but the industry needs to shift with Millennials in order to build trustworthy connections and positively influence long-term financial confidence.

You may be interested in:

Inflection Spotting

Inflection Spotting There’s a good chance that you’re lost right now. Perhaps something changed on your path, and you’re unaware that you’re headed in the wrong direction. The thing about being lost is that you’re usually lost for some time before you know...

What the Grocery Stores Holding Their Own Against Amazon Are Doing Right

What the Grocery Stores Holding Their Own Against Amazon Are Doing Right

by Amit Sharma
Harvard Business Review

A 2018 consumer survey by C Space found that shoppers were more likely to recommend and purchase repeatedly from brands that made them feel respected and understood.

The future of service stations

The future of service stations

by Ben Moncrieffe (C Space)
Quirk’s

As electric cars become more common, and consumers continue to seek outstanding CX, service stations and interstate rest stops need to rethink their purpose and design. 

Guy Kawasaki: Evangelist in Chief

Guy Kawasaki: Evangelist in Chief Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: Guy Kawasaki pioneered evangelism marketing. Starting in the mid-1980s as Chief Evangelist at Apple, Kawasaki spread the good gospel of the Macintosh computer. The product itself,...
Critical: Listening

Critical: Listening

Critical: Listening I was in New York City attending a conference on “social media listening” when a shelter-in-place alert flashed across my phone. In that moment, social media was what I wanted to listen to. Julie Wittes Schlack is...

Tom Colicchio: Lessons from the Chef

Tom Colicchio: Lessons from the Chef Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: Tom Colicchio is a James Beard Award-winning chef and owner of Crafted Hospitality, a restaurant group with restaurants across the U.S. He’s also a judge on “Top Chef,” Bravo’s...

The death and rebirth of the gas station

The death and rebirth of the gas station Gas stations are unique places. They sit at the intersection of retail, hospitality, energy, and mobility. But the truth is, without serious innovation, gas stations will end up like deserted Wild West Main Streets....

The Lifestyle Experience

The Lifestyle Experience Thirty years ago, the brand was advertising. TV and radio commercials, billboards, print ads – these, along with word-of-mouth, were just about the only interactions customers had with a brand before they bought its products,...

Tina Sharkey, Brandless CEO: It’s Gotta Have Soul

Tina Sharkey, Brandless CEO: It’s Gotta Have Soul Subscribe to the Outside In podcast: Tina Sharkey is an entrepreneurial force. Since the days of the dial-up modem, she has been building communities, companies, and brands “with soul.” Today, she’s...

What Retailers Need to Know to Own Customer Experience in the Apparel Industry

What Retailers Need to Know to Own Customer Experience in the Apparel Industry

by Robert Howie (C Space)
Apparel Magazine

Although the market has proven uncertain for several brands, retailers can survive these difficult times. For the apparel market to succeed in delivering better experiences for customers, it needs to go back to basics.